---Advertisement---

Sports

IND vs SL Super Over: Why Was Dasun Shanaka ‘Not Out’ despite broken stumps – The shocking 4th Ball controversy Explained

Super Over chaos in India vs Sri Lanka Asia Cup final as 4th ball controversy sparks confusion over caught behind and run-out.

IND vs SL Super Over: The Super Over in the India vs Sri Lanka Asia Cup 2025 final turned chaotic during the 4th ball, sparking confusion and debate across players and fans alike.

---Advertisement---

With Sri Lanka struggling at 2/1, Arshdeep Singh bowled a wide yorker to Dasun Shanaka, which was initially ruled caught behind by the on-field umpire. India celebrated, but Shanaka immediately opted for a review, believing he hadn’t edged it. Replays confirmed there was no contact with the bat – the decision was overturned.

---Advertisement---

However, chaos erupted when Shanaka attempted a run after missing the delivery, only to be run out by a direct hit from Samson. But here’s the twist, since the original decision was out (caught behind), the ball was dead immediately, making the run-out invalid.

---Advertisement---

Umpire Gazi Sohel had to clarify the rule, leaving even Indian players visibly puzzled. The confusion allowed Shanaka to survive despite the misjudgment – a rare scenario that had fans buzzing and rules experts pulling out the rulebooks.

What rule suggests?

According to the rules, the ball is considered dead as soon as the on-field umpire gives a batter out in the middle and since the decision was overturned, any action following the wicket, including the run out is considered void.

Rule 20.1.1.3 says that a ball is considered dead when the batter is dismissed. “The ball will be deemed to be dead from the instant of the incident causing the dismissal,” it reads.

Also, rule 3.7.1 states: If following a Player Review request, an original decision of Out is changed to Not out, then the ball is still deemed to have become dead when the original decision was made (as per clause 20.1.1.3). 

Therefore, despite being well short of his crease, Shanaka’s run out had to be reversed. The batter, however, fell off the very next ball restricting Sri Lanka to 2 for 2 in the Super Over.

India win the super over

Chasing a mare 3 runs, India skipper Suryakumar Yadav smashed the winning runs in the first ball to finish-off the Super-4 stage without loosing any game.

Though it didn’t change the outcome dramatically, the incident added a fresh layer of drama to an already nail-biting final.

Also Read: Suryakumar Yadav’s spin struggles or just a bad patch? Tilak Varma debate heats up ahead of Asia Cup 2025 Final

First published on: Sep 27, 2025 12:35 AM IST


Get Breaking News First and Latest Updates from India and around the world on News24. Follow News24 on Facebook, Twitter.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Related Story

Live News

---Advertisement---


live

Dhurandhar Box Office Collection LIVE Updates: Ranveer Singh’s film shows strong collection so far

Dec 05, 2025
Dhurandhar Box Office Collection LIVE Updates: Ranveer Singh’s film shows strong collection so far
  • 17:10 (IST) 5 Dec 2025

    Dhurandhar LIVE Updates: Box office collection so far

N24 Shorts Logo

SHORTS

India

What’s special about White Fortuner Modi chose for Putin? Was it a cover to look ordinary? Check its specs and credentials

What makes the white Toyota Fortuner Modi chose for Putin special. Was it a cover to look ordinary? Explore its full specs and credentials

View All Shorts

---Advertisement---

Trending