New Delhi, May 16: With the Karnataka power tussle turning into a midnight courtroom battle, the Supreme Court said the general trend of its past judgments was not to restrain the governor, as it heard a plea by the Congress-JD(S) combine against the governors decision to invite BJPs B S Yeddyurappa to form the government.
The apex court, during a rare post midnight hearing, also asked can it restrain the governor from inviting a party to form the government, to which senior lawyer and Congress leader A M Singhvi said the Supreme Court had done so in the past.
The court said was it not a convention that the single largest party gets invited by governor to form government and prove majority.
The three-judge bench, comprising justices A K Sikri, S A Bobde and Ashok Bhushan, said they are wondering whether the Supreme Court can restrain the governor that might lead to constitutional vacuum in the state.
The court also observed that the general trend of its past judgements was not to issue injunction or restrain the governor.
Over an hour into the hearing, the bench said that unless it sees BJPs letter, it would not know what kind of majority it has.
The court observed that it was preposterous to argue, before MLAs take oath, they were not amenable to anti-defection law and it meant it was an open invitation to horse-trading.
It also sought to know why the governor gave 15 days for floor test to the BJP and how it was claiming majority when the Cong-JD(S) combine has higher numbers.
Attorney General K K Venugopal said the swearing-in was subject to the outcome of floor test and the court can hear the matter after that.
With Singhvi arguing that the Constitution gives immunity to governor only for discharge of duties, the bench asked whether he wanted the court to scrutinise discretion of the governor when it does not have the letter given to Karnataka Governor Vajubhai Vala that was the basis for inviting the BJP to form the government.
Arguing on behalf of the Congress and JD(S), Singhvi told the bench, constituted by Chief Justice Dipak Misra to hear the matter, that the governor has negated democracy by not calling the alliance commanding majority in Karnataka.
"It is the biggest license to poaching if the governor gives 15 days to BJP to prove majority as in earlier such cases 48 hours were given by SC," Singhvi said.
He said the BJP has 104 MLAs and Governor invited B S Yeddyurappa to form govt in "unconstitutional manner", even as JD(S) leader HD Kumaraswamy along with the Congress has 116 MLAs supporting him.
Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, representing BJP and B S Yeddyurappa, said no injunction can be issued to the governor.
He argued that the matter should not have been heard at this hour and it was "absolutely wrong" to do so.
The bench commenced hearing on the matter at 2:11 AM. Attorney General Venugopal and ASG Maninder Singh were also in court on behalf of the Centre.
Hours after the Congress-JD(S) appraoched the CJI for an urgent hearing, the Supreme Court decided to hear the late night petition filed by the Congress and the JD(S) challenging Governor Valas decision to invite the BJP to form the government in the southern state.
The joint petition by Congress Karnataka unit chief G Parameshwara and H D Kumaraswamy sought a stay on the oath-taking ceremony, as communicated by the governor to the BJPs chief ministerial candidate B S Yeddyurappa.
In its midnight legal push, the Congress and JD (S) approached the Supreme Court seeking an immediate intervention by the chief justice to stay the move, which it termed as an "encounter of the Constitution".
The Congress urged Chief Justice Misra to hold an urgent hearing tonight itself since Yeddyurappa is slated to take oath as chief minister at 9 am tomorrow.
Singhvi said the party sought hearing on its petition challenging the governors decision tonight itself.
The Congress termed the governors decision as "murder of democracy and trampling of Constitution".
Earlier in the evening, Vala invited Yeddyurappa to form the government and take oath as chief minister tomorrow. He also asked Yeddyurappa to seek a vote of confidence within 15 days of assuming office.
Singhvi, who has been assigned the task to lead Congress legal challenge against Valas decision, had met the Supreme Court registrar to take forward the process to hear the "urgent petition".
The Congress has termed the move to form a BJP government in Karnataka as "illegal and against the law and Constitution."
The petition prepared by advocate Dev Dutt Kamath contended that despite presenting the list of 116 MLAs, governor Vala has invited the BJP which has 104 MLAs to form the government and has given relatively longer time of 15 days to prove the majority on the floor of the House.
The Congress has also said that granting 15 days time to Yeddyurappa to prove majority on the floor of the House will promote horse trading, alleging that BJP will resort to poaching of MLAs of Congress and JD(S).
The BJP has emerged as the single largest party in the southern state winning 104 seats, but is short of a simple majority.
On the other hand, the Congress and JD(S), which have already announced post-poll tie-up, have won 78 and 37 seats respectively and claimed before Vala to have numbers to form government in the state. PTI