The Delhi High Court on Monday quashed the CIC order that allowed access of details regarding Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bachelor degree.
While giving the verdict, Justice Sachin Datta quashed the CIC’s order that had directed the university to permit inspection of records relating to students who graduated with a Bachelor of Arts degree in 1978, the same year PM Modi completed his course.
The High Court had stayed the CIC order in January 2017, following Delhi University’s challenge.
The matter stemmed from an RTI application filed by one Neeraj, which led the CIC on December 21, 2016, to hold that universities are public institutions and their degree registers constitute public records accessible under the Right to Information Act.
Appearing for the Centre, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, argued in support of the university. The Solicitor General stressed that while records could be produced before the court if required, placing them in the public domain would serve individuals “seeking publicity or driven by political motives”.
He cautioned that an overly broad interpretation of the RTI Act could hinder the functioning of public authorities.
Delhi University also maintained that the degree records were held in a fiduciary capacity and that disclosure without a clear demonstration of public interest was not justified under the RTI Act.
