Although Stranger Things season 5 has the potential to revisit the emotional weight of season 4, critics warn that repeating Max’s storyline with another character, particularly Dustin, could backfire. Season 4 was celebrated for its intense subplot involving Max, played by Sadie Sink, and her confrontation with Vecna, the season’s primary antagonist.
Max’s Standout Subplot Defined Season 4
Introduced in season 2, Max evolved into a central figure of Stranger Things. Her arc in season 4 revolved around coping with the death of her abusive stepbrother Billy, whose heroic sacrifice in season 3 left her wracked with guilt. This vulnerability made her a target for Vecna, leading to the show’s iconic “Running Up That Hill” sequence. This scene, underscored by Kate Bush’s song, became a cultural phenomenon.
Parallels Between Dustin And Max’s Storylines
Season 5 hints at Dustin, portrayed by Gaten Matarazzo, grappling with grief over the loss of Eddie Munson, his mentor and friend. Eddie, a fan-favorite character, sacrificed himself during season 4’s finale. The show’s creators could be tempted to echo Max’s arc by having Dustin face Vecna’s manipulations, possibly with Eddie appearing as a spectral figure.
Critics argue that replicating Max’s subplot with Dustin risks undermining his unique role as comic relief. Unlike Max, who was often isolated, Dustin has a strong support network, including Steve Harrington and the rest of the gang. Gaten Matarazzo acknowledged Dustin’s grief in interviews but assured fans that his character remains true to his optimistic nature.
Also Read: MrBeast To Save TikTok! Former Offers To Buy Platform Amid U.S. Ban Threat; Netizens React!
Repetition Risks Overshadowing Season 5’s Stakes
Fans and critics agree that Stranger Things should prioritize resolving the series’ central conflict, with Eleven finally defeating Vecna. Rehashing season 4’s emotional beats with Dustin could feel redundant, detracting from the climactic battles and character growth anticipated in the final season.
Max’s vulnerability stemmed from her complicated feelings about Billy, whose abusive behavior left her conflicted even after his death. In contrast, Dustin’s grief over Eddie is uncomplicated, as Eddie was a clear hero. With strong emotional support from his friends, Dustin is unlikely to experience the same isolation that made Max’s arc so impactful.
Season 5 Set For Late 2025 Release
As Stranger Things gears up for its final chapter, fans eagerly await fresh twists and emotional depth. While Dustin’s grief will undoubtedly play a role, critics hope the show steers clear of retreading Max’s storyline, delivering an original and satisfying conclusion to the series.
